In Defense of Bookstores

The passage of HB2 in North Carolina is causing a great deal of concern in many quarters, rightfully so because there’s a lot that’s wrong with it, but reactions have not always been well thought out, in my opinion. I normally don’t use Buried Under Books as a forum for political issues but this goes beyond politics because bookstores are being treated unfairly when they’ve done nothing I’m aware of to warrant it. If you don’t agree, that’s OK; if you do, please let your local or not-so-local bookstores know you support them in any way you can. Better yet, please encourage any author you know to visit a bookshop in North Carolina.

The following is reprinted from Shelf Awareness; thanks to Kevin’s Corner for helping to spread the word.

Malaprop’s to Authors: Please Don’t Boycott Us

Linda Marie Barrett Malaprop's BookstoreLinda-Marie Barrett, general manager of Malaprop’s Bookstore/Café, Asheville, N.C., is sending this open letter to authors who are considering cancelling tour stops in North Carolina to protest the state’s new discriminatory law HB2:

Dear Authors,

Malaprop’s Bookstore/Cafe is an award-winning independent bookstore located in Asheville, N.C. For 34 years, we have promoted free speech, human rights and tolerance. We often suffer because of our stance: we’ve been the target of protests in front of our store, we’ve had our book choices challenged, and we’ve received threatening letters and phone calls from people who want us to cancel events because the views of the author are controversial. Not only do we hold these events, we protect the visiting author’s right to free speech with our words and sometimes our bodies.

We are located in a state that just passed a horrible piece of legislation: HB2. We have already hosted meetings in our store about HB2, and posted signs on our bathrooms to let everyone know they are safe to use whichever bathroom they wish. Our city council and mayor are currently considering an official statement and policy to act against state law, despite the consequences. We and our city will do what we can to repeal HB2.

Because of HB2, authors are cancelling events at our store. Sherman Alexie is the first to cancel an event we’d scheduled in May. Although we very much respect the reason he cancelled, the result is that we have lost an opportunity to connect this charismatic, inspiring author with those young readers who were going to see him on school visits. We also lost the opportunity to host him at a large venue, which would have connected him with fans in a city that stands with him and could have used his support. Our event could have served as a platform to address an audience that would be empowered by his outrage. We lost all these opportunities, and we are suffering financially because we anticipated selling 300-500 copies of his newest book, Thunder Boy, Jr.

We have read the open letter from children’s books authors and do not understand why bookstores are placed in a category outside of libraries and schools as places authors will still visit. The letter states, “We stand with those who share our guiding principles and fundamental beliefs of equality, inclusion, and fair treatment. Thus, we will continue to visit your schools and libraries. We will spread kindness and inspire compassion and hope, as we believe books, in their best moments, always have and always will.” We, as an independent bookstore, share those guiding principles and fundamental beliefs of equality, inclusion and fair treatment. We work hard every day to make sure that books are available to readers and to guard against censorship and intolerance in whatever form it appears.

If more authors boycott NC because of HB2, we will be financially stricken. We sympathize with their stance, but we hope that authors will choose another way to protest. By protesting in this manner, targeting bookstores, they are directly hurting their fiercest allies. Please don’t abandon us; we need your support now more than ever.

Malaprops Bookstore Cafe Logo


9 thoughts on “In Defense of Bookstores

  1. I wondered, when I read the title of this post, why bookstores needed defending. Now I understand. Malaprop’s is a store worth defending. Asheville is not a town that would stand with this indefensible law. I hope all of my fellow authors who are scheduled to appear at Malaprop will not cancel, but will show their defiance of this kind of bigotry by showing up. Protesting this law is the right thing to do, but don’t injure a bookstore that stands with you in the process.
    Kathleen Delaney
    Purebred Dead
    Curtains for Miss Plym


  2. Wow, I had no idea how bookstores would be affected because of HB2. I’m sorry that this happening, but it is the strongest way for people with influence to protest against HB2. I feel so torn about this because I love local bookstores and am a passionate supporter of the book industry, but LGBT rights is a personal issue for me.
    I do wish the good people of NC the best. I understand that not all of them agree with HB2 and there are many allies there. But the governor should have had more foresight.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.