Book Reviews: Good as Dead by Mark Billingham, Pocket-47 by Jude Hardin, Buried Secrets by Joseph Finder, and Hurt Machine by Reed Farrel Coleman

Good As Dead
Mark Billingham
Little, Brown, August 2011
ISBN: 978-1-84744-419-6
Hardcover, 392 pp., 16.99 BPS

[This book is the UK edition. It was released in the US in June 2012 by Mulholland Books under the title The Demands.]

This novel is the latest—the 10th—in the Tom Thorne series featuring a British cop of a different stripe.  His approach to solving a crime is to achieve a conclusion by any means.  And, in this book, he shows no mercy.

It begins when D.S. Helen Weeks enters her local news agent’s shop to buy her customary candy bar and ends up, along with another customer, as a hostage to the proprietor, who then demands that Thorne find the murderer of his son.  Some months before, Thorne had been the arresting officer when the boy surrendered for killing another lad in self-defense.  He received an eight-year sentence, rather an extreme incarceration based on the case.  While in prison, he was attacked and taken to the hospital where he was later found dead of an overdose of drugs.  His father refuses to accept the verdict that the death was a suicide.

Forced to reopen the case and “find the truth,” Thorne fights against time and Helen’s predicament.  The time frame of the novel is three days, which certainly speeds up the action both behind the closed doors of the shop, as well as vis-à-vis Thorne’s progress.  The psychological aspects of the hostage system:  the interchanges between Weeks and her captor, and the uncertainties of the situation, are manifested in the shifting conversations between the two.  In contrast are the fears and doubts of the police officials outside who cannot determine what, if any, efforts should be made to free the hostages and apprehend the news agent.  Thorne’s quick determination that the news agent’s belief is correct – – that rather than suicide, his son was murdered – – comes quickly, just as the various pieces of the puzzle are unveiled one by one.  Nevertheless, Thorne is really a delightful and intriguing character, and the well-written scenario moves forward briskly.  Recommended.

Reviewed by Ted Feit, September 2011.


Jude Hardin
Oceanview Publishing, May 2011
ISBN: 978-1-60809-011-2

I’m not sure the world needs another hard-boiled PI, but that is what we have in this debut effort, which has a hard time finding a consistent voice, and from time to time lapses into trite asides, for almost no reason.  Nevertheless, the book shows the author can write, and hopefully will settle on a method that doesn’t simply try to emulate Mickey Spillane (who, obviously, not only invented the genre, but is in a class by himself).

Nicholas Colt makes his territory in the Florida Panhandle and is retained by a woman to find and bring home her runaway 15-year-old sibling.  It doesn’t take him long to find the girl, holed up in the apartment of a pimp, and he takes her to his girlfriend’s apartment since the girl complains that she doesn’t want to go home since someone is out to kill her.  So he takes her the next day to his Airstream trailer, teaches her to fish, and then leaves her alone while he goes away for a short time.  In his absence she is kidnapped, setting the stage for a more complicated [and contrived] ending.

The title is another mystery to be solved, and the answer is almost beside the point, especially since it involves the death in an airplane crash of Colt’s wife and daughter 20 years earlier (another example of unnecessary and complicated contrivance in the novel). Let’s consider this book a learning experience, from which a much better effort will emerge.

Reviewed by Ted Feit, September 2011.


Buried Secrets
Joseph Finder
St. Martin’s Press, June 2011
ISBN: 978-0-312-37914-8

It is a hard task to review such a well-written novel, peopled by interesting characters and with a well-drawn plot, yet have reservations because it seems to reverberate with clichés.  There is Nick Heller, the second appearance by this former superspy turned Boston PI, who seems to be too good to be real.  He knows everyone and seems to be smarter than them all; and some of the other characters seem like cardboard figures, especially some of the FBI personnel.

Yet the book is exciting, even riveting, despite the fact that a major premise – – the loss of over a billion dollars by Marshall Marcus, an investment manager “who never had a losing quarter, unlike Warren Buffet” – – seems somewhat preposterous.  As does the source of the funds  he managed to “lose.”  The plot revolves around the kidnapping of Marcus’ daughter in an effort to force him to reveal a secret document which would provide a Russian oligarch business leverage. Marcus enlists Heller’s aid in rescuing the girl, and the chase is on.

Finder’s eye for detail is impressive, and he moves the story forward daring the reader to put the book down.  The action is at a pace almost too much to absorb, packed with all sorts of twists and turns. Despite the above reservations, this is a book to be read, and it is recommended.

Reviewed by Ted Feit, October 2011.


Hurt Machine
Reed Farrel Coleman
Tyrus Books, December 2011
ISBN: 978-1-4405-3202-3
[It should perhaps be noted that the book is also being released in trade paperback]

Unlike the previous six novels in the series, this book is a lot more introspective and deep since Moe Prager learns he has stomach cancer.  This leads to a lot of looking at the past and present and less at the lighter side of life.  But that does not stop the formidable Moe from undertaking another tough task, made especially hard by the time restraints of his daughter’s upcoming wedding in a week and his own possibly limited lifespan.

After a pre-wedding dinner, Moe’s ex-wife and PI partner, who left him years before, accosts him outside the restaurant, asking him to look into the murder of her estranged older sister, one of two EMTs who refused to assist a dying man at a high-end bistro where they were supposedly having lunch.  Moe doggedly takes on the task, and therein lies a tale.

The tone of this book is a lot different from its predecessors, necessarily so in light of Moe’s serious illness.  That does not, of course, take away from the plot; it only reinforces the intensity of the various elements.  It is written with power and passion [albeit sometimes with too much schmaltz].  Let’s hope the doctors can save Moe and that he returns to his old self.


Reviewed by Ted Feit, October 2011.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.